diff --git a/src/format.jl b/src/format.jl
index 86ea71e..2d6510b 100644
--- a/src/format.jl
+++ b/src/format.jl
@@ -65,6 +65,8 @@ get_stylesheet(::Nothing) = get_stylesheet(normpath(STYLESHEET_DIR, "skeleton.cs
 get_stylesheet(path::AbstractString) = read(path, String)
 
 get_highlight_stylesheet(mime, highlight_theme) =
+    get_highlight_stylesheet(mime, get_highlight_theme(highlight_theme))
+get_highlight_stylesheet(mime, highlight_theme::Type{<:Highlights.AbstractTheme}) =
     sprint((io, x) -> Highlights.stylesheet(io, mime, x), highlight_theme)
 
 const WEAVE_VERSION = try